The Challenges of Shoulder Injuries in Major League Baseball: Reynaldo López, Kyle Wright, and the Uncertainty of Pitching Careers
In Major League Baseball, few challenges are as persistent and career-threatening as shoulder injuries, especially for pitchers. The throwing shoulder endures tremendous strain through the repetitive motion of pitching—hundreds of times over the course of a season, often at velocities exceeding 90 miles per hour. Given the delicacy of the shoulder joint, even minor disruptions can have long-term consequences. As such, when a pitcher undergoes shoulder surgery or experiences related discomfort, it raises serious concerns—not just for their immediate health, but also for their career trajectory.
Recently, this has been the case with Reynaldo López, a right-handed pitcher for the Atlanta Braves. After undergoing arthroscopic shoulder surgery, there was an understandable wave of anxiety among Braves fans and baseball observers alike. While shoulder procedures are not uncommon, they often signal deeper issues. Thankfully for López and the Braves, his surgery revealed no structural damage—a considerable relief in a sport where clean imaging results are far from guaranteed. This outcome suggests his recovery time may be shorter than initially feared.
In contrast, the Braves have had less optimistic experiences with shoulder injuries in recent years. Kyle Wright, once a highly-touted pitching prospect and the fifth overall selection in the 2017 MLB Draft, has become a cautionary tale. Wright, who once starred as an ace for Vanderbilt University, appeared to be on the cusp of realizing his potential during his breakout 2022 season. That year, he put together a strong performance that finally validated the hype surrounding his draft pedigree. It seemed he had turned a corner, establishing himself as a dependable arm in Atlanta’s rotation.
However, Wright’s progress was abruptly derailed. By the seventh start of the 2023 season, shoulder soreness forced him to the sidelines. This setback proved to be more serious than initially hoped. Medical evaluations later concluded that he would require shoulder surgery, effectively ending his 2023 campaign and ruling him out for the entire 2024 season. As is often the case with such injuries, the prognosis was grim. Rehabilitation from shoulder surgery can be unpredictable, and for pitchers, regaining full form is often elusive.
The Braves’ front office, recognizing the uncertain timeline for Wright’s recovery and needing roster flexibility, made the decision to move on. In a calculated move, they traded Wright to the Kansas City Royals in 2024 in a deal that involved a swap of former first-round draft picks. While the trade had financial motivations—it helped the Braves shed salary—it also reflected their waning confidence in Wright’s ability to return to his prior form. Essentially, the Braves were signaling they didn’t believe Wright could bounce back from the injury in a meaningful way.
Now in 2025, early returns from the trade seem to vindicate Atlanta’s decision. Wright, after months of rehab and preparation, had begun a minor league rehab assignment with the Royals’ Double-A affiliate. He managed to pitch six innings over several appearances, a small but necessary step in his comeback effort. Unfortunately, just as hope was beginning to build, the Royals made a concerning announcement: Wright would be pulled from his next rehab start due to “shoulder fatigue.”
The organization offered a cautiously optimistic tone in their public statement, noting that Wright had been recalled from his rehab assignment and would simply skip a start or two to rest. While this might seem like a minor development, anyone familiar with the pattern of shoulder injuries in baseball knows it can be an ominous sign. Setbacks like these are often precursors to more serious complications, and for a pitcher already fighting an uphill battle, it can be discouraging.
This development paints a bleak picture for Wright’s chances of a full recovery. Shoulder fatigue, especially when it halts a carefully managed rehab assignment, can indicate the shoulder is not responding well to the rigors of pitching. It is particularly disheartening when considered alongside Wright’s career arc. Once viewed as a future cornerstone of the Braves’ rotation, Wright now faces an uncertain future with a new team that took a gamble on his potential.
Shoulder injuries, unlike elbow injuries (where Tommy John surgery has a relatively high success rate), carry much more ambiguity. Recovery timelines vary wildly, and many pitchers are never the same afterward. Even when structural damage is avoided—as was the case with Reynaldo López—rebuilding strength, mechanics, and confidence takes time. The kinetic chain involved in pitching is delicate, and any disruption in the shoulder can have a domino effect on a pitcher’s delivery, velocity, and overall effectiveness.
In López’s case, the news is comparatively good. His clean surgical outcome suggests a path back to the mound within a matter of weeks or a few months. Fans and analysts alike will be watching closely to see how he performs upon return, as setbacks are not uncommon, and even minor symptoms can reappear with increased workload. Still, the lack of structural damage is a positive foundation upon which he can rebuild.
Meanwhile, for Wright and the Royals, the story is more complicated. Kansas City took a chance on a player with significant upside but considerable risk. At best, they might still end up with a quality starter if Wright can complete his rehab and rediscover his 2022 form. At worst, they may have inherited a damaged asset who struggles to contribute meaningfully at the major league level. Only time will tell, but the early signs are troubling.
The human element of these stories often gets overlooked in the flurry of transactions and statistics. For Kyle Wright, this isn’t just about innings pitched or ERA—it’s about fighting to resurrect a career that once seemed destined for greatness. The emotional and mental strain of repeated rehab, coupled with the physical pain of injury, creates a challenging environment that few athletes successfully navigate. His perseverance is commendable, regardless of the final outcome.
López’s situation serves as a reminder that not all shoulder surgeries are created equal. With no structural damage, his outlook is far brighter, and the Braves can realistically expect him to return to their bullpen or rotation in due course. Yet even in his case, caution will rule the day. The Braves are unlikely to rush him back, understanding the fragility of the situation and the long-term importance of his health.
As the 2025 season progresses, both players will remain under the microscope. For the Braves, the Wright trade will be evaluated in hindsight based on both López’s performance and Wright’s trajectory. For the Royals, the decision to invest in a former first-round talent is a gamble that could either pay dividends or prove to be a misstep.
Ultimately, these stories reflect a larger truth in baseball: the fine line between success and setback is often drawn in the doctor’s office rather than on the field. Shoulder injuries can take promising careers and render them incomplete, leaving fans to wonder what might have been. But for every Kyle Wright facing another hurdle, there is a Reynaldo López, clinging to hope and working toward a return.
In the unforgiving world of professional sports, resilience is often the greatest skill a player can have. Both López and Wright are demonstrating that in different ways—one hoping to avoid the worst-case scenario, the other trying to climb back from it.
Leave a Reply