Kyle Schwarber may be on the brink of joining baseball’s ever-growing list of nine-figure contract earners, with industry insiders like ESPN’s Jeff Passan projecting the Philadelphia Phillies slugger as a prime candidate for a lucrative payday. As the final year of his current four-year, $79 million deal unfolds, Schwarber—set to make $20 million in 2025—is positioning himself as both an on-field asset and a clubhouse leader, which strengthens his case for a significant contract extension or a major deal in free agency.
The Case for $100 Million
According to Passan, Schwarber’s value transcends traditional metrics. While some may question whether a designated hitter approaching his mid-30s could command a deal north of $100 million, Schwarber is, as Passan puts it, “terminally productive.” He’s known for his elite power, postseason poise, and respected veteran presence. Passan argues that a four-year deal at an annual average of $25 million—totaling $100 million—is not only plausible but “eminently reasonable,” especially given the lack of marquee bats expected in the upcoming free agent class.
Despite being mostly limited to designated hitter duties, Schwarber’s consistent home run production, on-base skills, and leadership qualities make him one of the most valuable veteran bats in the game. If he continues to produce at his current clip, particularly during a potential playoff run, interest in his services will spike—whether from Philadelphia or elsewhere.
Schwarber Wants to Stay in Philly
From Schwarber’s perspective, remaining in Philadelphia is the ideal outcome. He’s publicly expressed a desire to continue his career with the Phillies, noting in a February interview with MLB.com that the interest is mutual and talks could intensify during spring camp or the regular season. However, with no deal finalized yet, the risk of entering free agency still looms.
For Schwarber, winning is the key to both team success and individual reward. He credits former teammate Jon Lester for the mantra that “the best way to get paid is to win,” a sentiment Schwarber embraces as he helps lead a Phillies roster that has remained relatively intact over the last few seasons.
Veteran Core, Championship Aspirations
Philadelphia’s postseason aspirations hinge heavily on its core group of players, and Schwarber is a central piece of that puzzle. The Phillies fell just short in 2024, losing to the Mets in the NLDS, but Schwarber remains confident in the roster’s potential. He believes continuity within the team, including many players who have now spent three to four seasons together, gives them an edge in 2025.
“We’ve had about the same core of players for the last, going on Year 3, Year 4, so we know what we have,” Schwarber said. “Everyone knows the lineup and everyone knows the pitchers’ names and the guys in the bullpen.”
Still, Schwarber acknowledges that simply having the names on paper won’t cut it—they’ll need execution, health, and chemistry to make another deep playoff run. With a few key offseason additions and an expectation that returning stars will continue to produce, Schwarber is optimistic this group has what it takes to win a championship.
Phillies’ Dilemma: Extend or Risk Losing Him?
The Phillies now face a pivotal decision: lock Schwarber up before the season ends or allow him to test the free agent market this winter. Waiting too long could backfire, especially if Schwarber has another strong campaign and draws multiple suitors in free agency. The team’s front office must weigh the risks of age and positional limitations against his offensive output and intangible value.
General Manager Dave Dombrowski has shown a willingness to invest in top-tier talent, and keeping Schwarber may help preserve continuity and stability, especially if the Phillies believe they are in a championship window.
Free Agency Outlook
If Schwarber hits free agency, he’ll be one of the most coveted bats available. His proven power, left-handed presence, and October reputation will likely attract interest from both contending teams in need of a DH and rebuilding clubs looking for a veteran cornerstone.
Given the weak projected class of free agent hitters, Schwarber’s market value could soar. Teams like the Chicago Cubs (his former team), Texas Rangers, or even the San Francisco Giants—each in need of more power—might come calling. But if Philadelphia acts soon, it could avoid a bidding war and retain one of the game’s most consistent power hitters.
In summary, Kyle Schwarber appears poised to secure a $100 million contract, whether from the Phillies or on the open market. With a clear desire to stay in Philadelphia and the tools to back up a big payday, the decision now lies with the front office. If they believe in his continued productivity and leadership, striking a deal sooner rather than later could solidify their core and boost their title hopes. If not, Schwarber could be the marquee free agent of the 2025 offseason.
Would you like a projected contract breakdown or comparison to similar DHs who’ve signed nine-figure deals?
Leave a Reply