Could Phillies Be in the Market for New Shutdown Closer at Trade Deadline?

Yes, the Philadelphia Phillies could be in the market for a new shutdown closer as the MLB trade deadline approaches. The recent 80-game suspension of José Alvarado for a positive PED test has left a significant void in the bullpen, and the team’s current closer situation is uncertain. While Alvarado is to return in 2026, his absence this season has prompted the Phillies to explore potential bullpen reinforcements.

 

Jordan Romano, who was signed in December 2024, has struggled to regain his All-Star form, with a 5.81 ERA among late-inning relievers. This has led to speculation that the Phillies might seek a more reliable option to bolster their bullpen.

Several prominent relievers have been linked to the Phillies in trade rumors:

Mason Miller (Oakland Athletics): The 25-year-old closer has been dominant, recording a 2.40 ERA and 12 saves. His high velocity and effectiveness make him a prime target for teams like the Phillies.

Ryan Helsley (St. Louis Cardinals): The two-time All-Star closer posted a 2.04 ERA and 49 saves in 2024. With the Cardinals in rebuilding mode, Helsley could be available at the deadline.

Tanner Scott (Miami Marlins): A left-handed reliever with a 1.42 ERA and 13 saves, Scott is expected to be a free agent after the season, potentially making him a cost-effective acquisition.

Paul Sewald (Arizona Diamondbacks): With a 3.12 ERA and 11 saves, Sewald offers postseason experience and could be an attractive option for the Phillies.

Given the Phillies’ current bullpen depth, any trade would likely focus on acquiring a reliever who can provide a significant upgrade over existing options. The team’s front office, led by President of Baseball Operations Dave Dombrowski, has a history of making bold moves to strengthen the roster, particularly when aiming for a World Series run.