Aaron Judge: At the Heart of the Yankees and the All-Star Game Conversation
It was a quiet afternoon in the New York Yankees clubhouse, the sort of stillness that often follows intense practice or a demanding game. Amid the hum of subdued conversation and the rustle of gear bags, infielder Pablo Reyes made his way to Aaron Judge. With a playful smile on his face and his smartphone glowing in hand, Reyes approached the Yankees’ towering team captain.
“I just voted for you,” Reyes said, holding out his phone to show a freshly submitted All-Star ballot from MLB.com.
- Judge responded with a fist bump and a warm chuckle—an easy, appreciative moment between teammates. In an environment filled with top-tier talent, it was a small but significant reminder of who commands center stage in the Bronx. For Reyes, it was more than a friendly gesture; it symbolized the admiration and respect Judge commands not just from fans but from those who suit up beside him every day.
That same scene—someone eagerly submitting an All-Star vote for Aaron Judge—is being repeated all over the country as voting for the 2025 MLB All-Star Game gains momentum. The prestigious exhibition, scheduled for July 15 at Truist Park in Atlanta, will showcase the sport’s biggest stars, and Judge is once again poised to be a major figure.
Last year, Judge earned a guaranteed starting position in the American League lineup after leading all players in Phase 1 of the fan vote. It marked his sixth All-Star selection—an impressive milestone that speaks to both his popularity and sustained excellence. Based on his performance so far in the 2025 season, another All-Star nod seems all but certain.
A Season for the Ages
Judge has kicked off the year in remarkable fashion. His early-season stats are nothing short of breathtaking: leading Major League Baseball in batting average, on-base percentage, slugging percentage, OPS, hits, and extra-base hits. As of now, Judge is batting an astounding .396, with an on-base percentage over .490, and a slugging percentage topping .770—numbers that suggest not just an MVP-caliber campaign but one that may be etched into the annals of baseball history.
Fans, analysts, and even his former teammates are taking notice. Among them is Kyle Higashioka, now with the Texas Rangers, who caught for Judge during the early days of his career. Higashioka is amazed—not by Judge’s power, which has always been a hallmark of his game—but by his transformation into one of the most complete hitters in baseball.
“The .400 thing is what’s crazy,” Higashioka admitted. “That’s just nuts. His power has never surprised me, but the consistency at the plate—man, he’s on another level.”
It wasn’t always this way. Back in 2016, Judge had a forgettable debut stint in the Majors, hitting just .179. That humbling start left such a mark on him that he typed the number into a note on his iPhone—a quiet but powerful reminder of where he began and how far he’s come. It’s still there today, a digital motivation to keep striving for excellence.
Higashioka recalls that period well. “He was so disappointed in how he performed that he completely changed his swing in 2017,” he said. “He didn’t want to be just another player. He wanted to be the best version of himself. That drive? That’s what separates him.”
Evolution of a Superstar
Aaron Judge’s journey is more than a story of athletic achievement; it’s a masterclass in resilience and personal growth. After that difficult rookie year, Judge exploded onto the scene in 2017, winning AL Rookie of the Year and finishing second in the MVP race. Over the following seasons, injuries and inconsistency at times slowed his pace, but Judge never lost sight of the work.
Each year, he added more layers to his game—refining his plate discipline, adjusting to different pitching styles, improving his leadership. When he was named Yankees captain in 2023, it felt like a natural culmination of both his performance and his character. As the leader of one of baseball’s most storied franchises, Judge now carries the weight of legacy on his shoulders—and he seems built for it.
Few understand that pressure better than Rob Refsnyder, now with the Red Sox, who was Judge’s roommate during their Minor League days. Refsnyder has had a front-row seat to Judge’s evolution and remains one of his closest friends in the game.
“What he’s doing right now is incredible,” Refsnyder said. “And what makes it harder is the way teams pitch to him. They’re bringing in top-tier relievers early just to avoid letting Judge see the same pitcher three times. That’s respect—and fear.”
He added, “He’s going to be remembered as one of the greatest Yankees ever. When you see his name mentioned alongside Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig, that’s not hype. That’s real.”
The All-Star Stage Beckons
The MLB All-Star Game is not just a celebration—it’s a showcase, a stage for the sport’s most dazzling talents. And Judge, with his towering frame, powerful swing, and humble demeanor, is a perfect ambassador. Watching him compete among the game’s elite is not just a treat for Yankees fans, but for anyone who loves baseball.
As voting enters full swing, Judge’s name will be one of the first checked off by fans across the country. The first phase of voting continues through June 26 at noon ET, and if the current trends hold, Judge will once again headline the American League roster.
It’s worth remembering that the All-Star Game is also a reflection of the public’s appreciation—not just for flashy stats, but for the people behind them. Judge is not just a great player. He’s also admired for his professionalism, consistency, and leadership.
And as for what Judge thinks about the hype? He remains characteristically grounded.
“I try to focus on the situation at hand,” he said in a recent interview. “Whether I’m hitting .170 or .300, it’s about doing my job. If there are runners on base, I need to drive them in. If the bases are empty, it’s my job to get on and spark something. I don’t even look at the stats until the season’s over.”
A Model of Consistency
That mindset—stoic, focused, team-first—is what makes Judge so respected in baseball circles. In a world that often celebrates flash over substance, Judge remains firmly grounded. It’s not that he isn’t aware of the buzz around his Triple Crown potential or flirtation with a .400 average—it’s that he refuses to let it change him.
And that’s part of why fans vote for him in droves.
Whether you’re a diehard Yankees fan or simply a baseball purist, Judge embodies the qualities you want in a superstar. He’s not just a slugger; he’s a strategist. Not just a captain; a mentor. Not just an icon; a man grounded by a number—.179—typed into his phone nearly a decade ago.
Conclusion: A Vote for More Than Just Stats
So when Pablo Reyes cast his All-Star vote, he wasn’t just acknowledging Judge’s dominant stats. He was honoring a teammate, a leader, and a symbol of what perseverance and humility can achieve.
And when fans cast their ballots in the coming days, they too will be voting for more than just a batting line. They’ll be voting for a story—one that began with struggles, grew through hard work, and now shines as one of the most compelling in baseball.
Aaron Judge is having one of the greatest seasons in recent memory. And when the best of the best gather in Atlanta this July, there’s no question he belongs right in the middle of it.
Leave a Reply