Phillies Face All-Star Voting Snubs Despite Strong 2025 Rebound
As the calendar advances through June, so does the fan-driven selection process for the 2025 MLB All-Star Game, set to take place in Atlanta. For the Philadelphia Phillies, hopes are high to once again send a strong group of players to the Midsummer Classic. However, early voting returns suggest that the team’s standout performances aren’t getting the recognition they merit. Despite a shaky start to the season, the Phillies have regained their footing and appear poised for a strong finish—but time is running out to translate that success into All-Star votes.
The first official update of All-Star voting was released on Monday, and it revealed several notable omissions involving Philadelphia players. With Phase 1 of the fan vote set to close on June 26, Phillies fans have only a short window left to boost their favorites into contention.
Kyle Schwarber: A Power Threat Overlooked
Kyle Schwarber, the Phillies’ slugging designated hitter, has continued to demonstrate his game-changing ability at the plate. Known for his raw power and disciplined approach, Schwarber has clubbed 22 home runs—among the league’s best. Still, he’s been overshadowed by bigger names in the voting process. As of the first ballot update, Schwarber ranks fourth among National League DHs with 332,097 votes.
At the top of the list is none other than Shohei Ohtani, the two-way superstar now suiting up for the Los Angeles Dodgers. Ohtani has amassed a staggering 1,398,771 votes and leads all NL designated hitters in home runs with 25. While Schwarber’s numbers are impressive, they pale in comparison to Ohtani’s transcendent popularity and production. Beating Ohtani in any public vote is a monumental challenge, and Schwarber is clearly feeling that pressure.
Current Top 5 NL DH Voting:
- Shohei Ohtani (Dodgers): 1,398,771
- Rafael Devers (Giants): 796,382
- Seiya Suzuki (Cubs): 358,138
- Kyle Schwarber (Phillies): 332,097
- Starling Marte (Mets): 244,421
Alec Bohm: Undervalued Despite Consistent Play
Third baseman Alec Bohm is another Phillie whose All-Star case deserves more attention. After a rough April in which he batted just .221, Bohm has rebounded impressively. Since May 1, he has posted a 1.6 fWAR—second among all NL third basemen, trailing only the Padres’ Manny Machado. His overall batting average has climbed to .285, and his OPS sits at .727.
Yet, Bohm finds himself buried in fifth place in the voting with only 232,469 votes. He trails Matt Shaw of the Cubs by a slim margin and remains well behind Machado’s commanding lead. Despite his statistical resurgence, Bohm may not gather enough late support to make a second straight All-Star appearance.
Current Top 5 NL 3B Voting:
- Manny Machado (Padres): 955,122
- Max Muncy (Dodgers): 415,750
- Eugenio Suárez (D-backs): 290,138
- Matt Shaw (Cubs): 245,102
- Alec Bohm (Phillies): 232,469
Trea Turner: Elite Season Hidden Behind Star Power
Shortstop Trea Turner has arguably been the Phillies’ most complete player this season, yet his name remains underrepresented in fan voting. Turner’s current tally of 348,053 votes places him third among NL shortstops—behind Mookie Betts and Francisco Lindor. The numbers, however, paint a very different picture of Turner’s value.
Statistically, Turner leads all National League shortstops in fWAR (3.2), outpacing both Lindor (2.9) and Betts (2.1). He’s slashing .324/.367/.533 since May 1 and owns a .900 OPS during that stretch. His 2.4 fWAR over that period is the highest of any NL shortstop—nearly a full win above Lindor, the next closest.
Turner also leads the league in hits with 90 and holds a .308 season average with an .831 OPS. His speed has returned with a vengeance; he’s swiped 19 bags already, surpassing last year’s total in 51 fewer games. Additionally, his defense has improved markedly, earning praise for his agility and range.
Despite these credentials, Turner is stuck behind two of the league’s most recognizable names, showing how star power and fan familiarity often outweigh pure performance.
Current Top 5 NL SS Voting:
- Francisco Lindor (Mets): 1,019,273
- Mookie Betts (Dodgers): 597,188
- Trea Turner (Phillies): 348,053
- Elly De La Cruz (Reds): 312,538
- Dansby Swanson (Cubs): 307,173
Recognition vs. Performance: A Common Theme
The Phillies aren’t necessarily putting up gaudy offensive numbers across the board, but several players are enjoying standout seasons. Unfortunately, the nature of All-Star voting—largely driven by name recognition and media exposure—doesn’t always reward players based on recent performance or advanced metrics.
Last year, Philadelphia sent an impressive eight players to the All-Star Game in Texas. This year, barring a late voting surge or strong second-half pushes recognized by coaches and players in later voting phases, the Phillies may fall well short of that number.
The team still has plenty to be proud of, though. Players like Schwarber, Bohm, and Turner are producing at elite levels, and the Phillies’ turnaround after a rocky start shows the character and depth of the roster. Whether or not that translates into All-Star nods remains to be seen—but it certainly should.
Leave a Reply