Indiana Fever Face Early Test as Caitlin Clark Sidelined by Injury
The Indiana Fever kicked off the 2025 WNBA season with their sights firmly set on a championship run—and with solid justification. After a standout offseason, the Fever’s front office put together a dynamic blend of seasoned pros and rising talents. Veteran forward DeWanna Bonner and energetic guard Sophie Cunningham were two key acquisitions who bolstered the depth and experience of the squad. When combined with the team’s existing foundation—headlined by standout rookies-turned-core-players Caitlin Clark, Kelsey Mitchell, and Aliyah Boston—the Fever transformed from hopeful underdogs into genuine title contenders almost overnight.
However, that path to postseason glory has just hit its first real obstacle.
The team announced on Monday that Caitlin Clark, their marquee star, will be sidelined for a minimum of two weeks due to a left quadriceps injury. The timing couldn’t be more critical, as the regular season is still in its early stages and momentum is far from settled.
So far, Indiana has split their first four games, sitting at 2-2. Their season debut was a statement, dismantling the Chicago Sky by over 30 points in a dominating performance. But following that emphatic win, the Fever found themselves in increasingly competitive battles.
They suffered two heartbreaking defeats—first against the Atlanta Dream, where they nearly erased a large deficit only to fall short by a single point. Then they took on the reigning champion, New York Liberty, playing them closely before narrowly losing by two points. Despite Clark’s presence, these tight losses underscored just how competitive the league is—and how thin the margin of error can be.
Now, without Clark’s scoring, playmaking, and leadership, fans and analysts alike are wondering: can the Fever stay afloat, or even thrive, during this stretch without their biggest star? Will they rise to the moment or stumble under the pressure?
Here are three bold predictions about what lies ahead for Indiana as they navigate this critical stretch without Caitlin Clark.
1. Kelsey Mitchell Will Emerge as the Fever’s Top Scorer
One of the players poised to take a leading role in Clark’s absence is Kelsey Mitchell—a player whose consistent scoring prowess often flies under the radar.
Since joining the Fever as the No. 2 overall pick in 2018, Mitchell has been a model of offensive consistency. She has averaged over 17.5 points per game in every season since 2020 and has twice been named a WNBA All-Star. Even with Clark on the roster, Mitchell has frequently played a pivotal role in the Fever’s offense.
While many eyes have been on Clark since her arrival, Mitchell’s ability to score from all areas of the court makes her just as dangerous. Her range stretches well beyond the three-point line, and she’s equally adept at pushing the pace in transition or slicing through defensive gaps with crafty drives.
It’s not a stretch to predict that Mitchell will step up as the team’s leading scorer during Clark’s recovery. In fact, it may be the most straightforward expectation. With more touches and increased responsibility, Mitchell is likely to lead the team in points every night—or at the very least, carry the highest scoring average throughout this period.
Mitchell’s experience and versatility make her a steadying force for Indiana, and she’s no stranger to shouldering the offensive load. Fans can expect her to embrace this challenge with determination and efficiency as she helps guide the team through this rough patch.
2. Sydney Colson Will Set a Career High in Minutes Played
Another key ripple effect of Clark’s injury is the elevation of veteran guard Sydney Colson into the starting lineup. The Fever have already confirmed that Colson will step in as the starting point guard beginning with Wednesday’s game.
Colson, who entered the WNBA in 2011, brings more than a decade of professional experience, though she has rarely been a starter. Across her career, she has started only 10 games, typically serving as a backup who provides leadership and energy off the bench.
In the early games of the 2025 season, Colson has played sparingly—totaling just 24 minutes and scoring only four points. Her role has been limited, especially with Clark commanding the lion’s share of point guard duties.
That will now change dramatically.
With Clark unavailable, Colson will likely see her minutes skyrocket, potentially reaching levels she has never experienced before in her WNBA career. She’ll be expected not only to facilitate the offense but also to help maintain composure and cohesion on the court.
While she may not be a prolific scorer, Colson’s veteran savvy, court vision, and leadership are intangibles that could prove invaluable during this transition period. Whether it’s helping younger players like Aliyah Boston or coordinating the team’s defensive sets, her expanded role will give her the chance to make a meaningful impact—and possibly record the highest average minutes per game of her entire career.
3. Indiana Will Fight Their Way to a Winning Record Without Clark
With Clark sidelined, many fans might fear that the team’s playoff hopes could take a nosedive. However, this adversity might just serve as a rallying cry for the rest of the roster.
There’s still considerable talent available. In addition to Mitchell, the team can lean heavily on Aliyah Boston, whose post play and rebounding anchor the interior. Bonner’s leadership and scoring touch add veteran reliability, while Cunningham brings grit and energy that could help spark runs during tight games.
The Fever have shown in close losses that they can compete with the league’s best. The defeats to the Dream and the Liberty—each by only a single possession—suggest that with just a little more execution, they’re more than capable of turning close contests into wins.
Clark’s absence may force Indiana to play with greater discipline, share the ball more evenly, and find new on-court chemistry. In doing so, they could become an even more cohesive team. It’s reasonable to predict that the Fever can secure a winning record over the next several games, using defense, depth, and determination to carry them through.
Conclusion: A Crucial Chapter Begins
Injuries are always unwelcome in sports, especially when they affect superstar players like Caitlin Clark. But for the Indiana Fever, this challenge presents an opportunity to test their resilience, depth, and ability to adapt.
With Kelsey Mitchell likely to take the scoring reins, Sydney Colson stepping into a bigger role, and the rest of the team working to support one another, this stretch could reveal more about Indiana’s character than any blowout win ever could.
While Clark recovers, the Fever must keep their championship hopes alive by proving they are more than just a one-star show. The next few weeks will show whether this team is built to withstand adversity—or whether their rapid rise needs a bit more time to fully mature.
Leave a Reply