New York Yankees May Trade Reliable Reliever Luke Weaver Before 2025 Deadline Despite Decent Performance
As Major League Baseball’s trade deadline for the 2025 season quickly approaches, the New York Yankees find themselves in a delicate position. With only hours left before the buzzer sounds at 6 p.m. on July 31, the team may be preparing to part ways with one of its most reliable bullpen arms. According to Fansided journalist Thomas Carannante, the Yankees could be poised to make a surprise move by trading reliever Luke Weaver—despite his steady output during a season that’s been rocky for the Bronx Bombers.
In Carannante’s view, Weaver, whose contract is nearing its expiration, is a prime candidate for a deadline deal. Though the pitcher has remained relatively effective, his recent struggles combined with the Yankees’ uncertain status in the playoff race have fueled speculation. While he’s not dominating in terms of statistics, Weaver’s track record and versatility could make him a valuable trade asset—especially as the team reevaluates its strategy heading into the final months of the regular season.
Evaluating Luke Weaver’s Performance and Value
Weaver’s 2025 season has been a rollercoaster of highs and lows. In April, he surprised many by taking over the closer role from Devin Williams, delivering solid innings under pressure. However, a hamstring injury sidelined him for three weeks—a period that disrupted his momentum and raised questions about his reliability.
Since returning from the injured list, Weaver has not been the same. His earned run average (ERA) currently sits at 3.18. While that number might not dazzle on its own, it is, notably, the third-lowest ERA he’s posted since entering the majors in 2016 with the St. Louis Cardinals. This level of consistency has helped keep him in the conversation as a dependable option in a Yankees bullpen that has otherwise been up and down.
It’s worth noting that relief pitching, especially late-inning effectiveness, has become a glaring weakness for the Yankees this year. In past seasons, the bullpen was a cornerstone of the team’s success, but injuries and inconsistency have left them scrambling. With Gerrit Cole and Clarke Schmidt both out for the remainder of the season, the team’s pitching depth has taken a significant hit. While Weaver has provided some stability, he may also represent one of the few trade chips that could fetch immediate help for the rotation.
The Front Office Dilemma: Rebuild or Rebalance?
One of the most pressing issues facing Yankees management is how to approach the remainder of the 2025 campaign. The team hasn’t signaled a full rebuild, but it also isn’t acting like a squad that’s going all-in. Instead, the front office seems to be walking a fine line—looking to stay competitive without committing too many resources to a roster riddled with question marks.
This balancing act makes Weaver’s situation particularly complicated. On one hand, he’s shown enough promise to warrant a contract extension, especially given how thin the Yankees’ bullpen has been this year. On the other hand, his expiring deal and dip in performance post-injury make him a logical trade candidate if the team hopes to extract value now rather than risk losing him for nothing in free agency.
Carannante suggested that the Yankees may look to trade Weaver now, finish the season with internal options, and then pursue a reunion in the offseason. This “sell now, buy later” strategy could help them acquire depth for a battered rotation while preserving the possibility of bringing Weaver back on a new deal—likely with less financial risk if his struggles continue.
Recent Trade Moves Suggest More Activity Is Coming
So far, the Yankees have been relatively active in the trade market—just not when it comes to pitching. They’ve already acquired three position players: Ryan McMahon, Amed Rosario, and Austin Slater. These additions have helped shore up an infield and outfield that had its own issues, ranging from injuries to inconsistent performance.
However, bolstering the lineup alone won’t be enough to solidify a playoff spot. The American League remains tightly contested, and without reinforcements on the mound, New York’s postseason hopes could slip away. The front office appears to understand this, which is why the focus has reportedly shifted to pitching—both in the bullpen and the starting rotation.
The decision to potentially trade Weaver may come down to how much another team is willing to offer. If a contender in need of bullpen help is willing to part with a promising young arm or a back-end starter, the Yankees might feel that the short-term loss is worth the long-term gain.
Weaver’s Career Path to This Point
Luke Weaver’s MLB journey began in 2016 when he debuted with the St. Louis Cardinals. Over the years, he has carved out a respectable career, playing for several teams, including the Arizona Diamondbacks and Kansas City Royals, before landing in New York. While never a superstar, Weaver has long been appreciated for his resilience, command, and ability to adapt.
What sets Weaver apart is his versatility. He has experience as both a starter and a reliever, making him an attractive option for teams that need a Swiss Army knife in their pitching staff. Though he has been primarily used out of the bullpen in New York, his previous experience as a starter could be valuable for a club that needs rotation help heading into the stretch run.
Given his background, Weaver could be a useful asset for a playoff contender—particularly one looking for depth and experience in high-pressure situations. If the Yankees do decide to move him, they’re likely to find no shortage of interested parties, especially in a year where effective pitching is in high demand across the league.
Why the Yankees Might Hold On
Despite the speculation, there are reasons why New York might choose to keep Weaver for the remainder of the season. For one, the bullpen has been unpredictable. Losing one of their most reliable options—especially one who has already demonstrated he can handle closing duties—could backfire if replacements don’t step up.
Another factor is clubhouse chemistry. Weaver is said to be well-liked among his teammates and respected for his work ethic. Trading him could send the wrong message to a team that’s still within striking distance of a playoff berth. It would signal a shift toward next year when there’s still time to salvage this one.
Then there’s the contractual angle. If the Yankees believe they have a real shot at re-signing Weaver this winter, keeping him could offer a continuity advantage. Letting him walk into another team’s system now could complicate negotiations down the road.
Teams That Could Be Interested in Weaver
If the Yankees put Weaver on the trade block, several teams could emerge as potential suitors. Contenders dealing with bullpen injuries or inconsistency might see him as a low-risk, high-reward addition. Teams like the Philadelphia Phillies, Houston Astros, or even the Milwaukee Brewers—who know Weaver well from his NL days—could all be in the mix.
Weaver’s manageable contract, playoff experience, and ability to pitch in multiple roles make him a desirable option for teams looking to fine-tune their roster. If the Yankees decide to make him available, there will likely be enough demand to spark a bidding war, allowing the front office to extract maximum value.
The Broader Strategy at Play
The situation with Weaver is emblematic of a broader strategic conundrum facing the Yankees. After a string of postseason disappointments and underwhelming finishes, the franchise is at a crossroads. Should they hold steady and push for one last run in 2025, or pivot toward a more future-oriented approach?
Trading Weaver could be the first domino in a series of moves designed to reshape the roster without tearing it all down. It would allow the Yankees to add younger arms or controllable assets while still remaining competitive in the short term. Alternatively, keeping Weaver might signal a renewed push to strengthen the bullpen from within and chase a playoff berth more aggressively.
Either way, the next 24 hours are crucial. The deadline isn’t just about making trades—it’s about signaling intent. For Yankees fans, Weaver’s fate may provide a window into how the organization truly views the remainder of the season.
Final Thoughts
As the 2025 trade deadline looms, the Yankees are at a pivotal moment. Luke Weaver, a reliever with solid credentials and a complicated trajectory this season, finds himself in the spotlight. Whether the team chooses to hold onto him or deal him for reinforcements, the decision will reverberate far beyond the bullpen.
If Weaver is moved, it would mark a calculated gamble—one that could either provide the rotation depth the Yankees desperately need or leave the bullpen more vulnerable in the season’s most critical stretch. If he stays, fans can expect him to continue playing a key role, possibly even returning to the closer’s role if his form improves.
No matter the outcome, Weaver’s story underscores the stakes involved as teams across the league navigate one of the most unpredictable trade deadlines in recent memory. With injuries mounting and the standings tightening, every move counts—and for the Yankees, this one could define their season.
Leave a Reply