Sophie Cunningham’s Online Joke Sparks Unexpected Backlash from Caitlin Clark Fans — But Is the Criticism Justified?
Sophie Cunningham has long been known not just for her hustle and grit on the hardwood but also for her outspoken personality and playful provocations off the court. She’s no stranger to using social media as a stage for jokes, sarcasm, and light-hearted commentary. However, her most recent post struck a nerve with a segment of the WNBA fanbase—particularly those closely aligned with her high-profile teammate, Caitlin Clark.
In what might’ve been intended as a humorous social media gag, the Indiana Fever guard reshared a meme referencing a popular online trope: the “trumpet guy” meme. In this image, one person plays a loud trumpet directly into someone else’s ear, annoying them. In Cunningham’s repost, the trumpeter was labeled “Caitlin,” while the irritated girl next to her was tagged as “Sophie,” with Fever teammate Lexie Hull making an appearance too. Cunningham captioned the meme with, “I’ve never seen anything more true,” seemingly poking fun at the endless chatter or media attention Clark receives.
But what may have been light-hearted in tone didn’t land well with all fans—especially supporters of Clark, the sophomore sensation who has transformed the Fever’s national spotlight and elevated WNBA viewership this season. For some, the meme wasn’t merely a playful jab; they viewed it as a slight, even borderline disrespectful, coming from someone who benefits from being on the same team as the league’s most talked-about star.
Fans React: When Humor Meets Fandom Sensitivities
Clark’s rapidly growing fanbase is famously passionate and protective. So when Cunningham posted the meme, they wasted little time in voicing displeasure. The backlash erupted across social media, with many fans interpreting the joke as a dig toward the 23-year-old Iowa alum who has revitalized interest in the league.
One particularly biting comment read: “I wouldn’t bite the hand that feeds you.” Another chimed in, “Without Clark, would anyone even know you exist? Ever think of posting something about yourself for once?”
Several replies echoed this same sentiment: that Cunningham—and even Hull—have seen increased visibility largely because of Clark’s celebrity. The implication was that the meme wasn’t just teasing—it was ungrateful.
But others argued that these reactions ignored the true nature of the post. Cunningham has long operated with a playful, sarcastic edge on her social media accounts. This latest meme, her defenders said, was just another entry in a well-documented pattern of jesting that reflects a healthy team dynamic, not hidden animosity.
More Than Just Teammates: The Real Bond Between Clark and Cunningham
What’s important to consider—especially amid the current social media frenzy—is that there’s no visible sign of actual tension between Cunningham and Clark. In fact, the two players have consistently showcased mutual admiration and camaraderie on and off the floor throughout the 2025 WNBA season.
Cunningham has been one of Clark’s most vocal advocates. During games, she’s shown fierce loyalty, even risking ejections to defend her teammate. One standout moment came in a matchup against the Connecticut Sun when Clark was involved in a physical altercation with opposing guard Jacy Sheldon. Cunningham immediately rushed in and confronted Sheldon, leading to her ejection. That moment, while controversial, was interpreted by many as a clear sign of the trust and protection Sophie extends toward Caitlin. It sent a strong message: if you go after Clark, you’ll have to deal with Cunningham.
And this dynamic doesn’t end on the court. In earlier interviews, Cunningham gushed about her relationship with Clark, saying, “We really do love each other, love spending time together.” That kind of comment contradicts the narrative that Sophie might harbor ill feelings or envy toward her more famous teammate. If anything, their connection appears stronger than ever.
Social Media, Sarcasm, and Sophie Cunningham’s Unapologetic Style
To truly understand the situation, one must first understand Cunningham’s personality. Since her early years in the WNBA with the Phoenix Mercury, Sophie has embraced a public persona that combines fiery competitiveness with a sardonic, humorous tone. She’s never been one to hold back, and her online presence has always been laced with jokes, memes, and the occasional troll-like humor. It’s a big part of what makes her endearing to her own fans—and occasionally polarizing to others.
When Sophie joined the Indiana Fever, she brought that same energy with her. The Fever, a team undergoing a cultural and competitive transformation, seemed like the perfect landing spot for a veteran who plays with edge and attitude. And alongside Caitlin Clark—a star drawing intense media scrutiny and fan engagement—Cunningham’s antics were always likely to attract more attention, both positive and negative.
But the meme incident reveals a broader challenge in sports culture today: how teammates of superstar athletes navigate public perception. For players like Cunningham and Hull, who have carved their own respected paths in the league, their proximity to Clark sometimes invites unfair assumptions. The idea that their careers are somehow wholly dependent on Clark erases their prior achievements.
Lexie Hull and the “Clark Effect” Misconception
Lexie Hull’s involvement in the meme also drew criticism. But like Cunningham, Hull has a strong résumé independent of Clark. The former Stanford Cardinal standout was an NCAA champion and a highly-touted draft pick. She’s also a WNBA Commissioner’s Cup winner, helping lead the Fever to victory in the midseason tournament—an accomplishment earned without Clark on the court, as the star guard was sidelined with injury.
To suggest that Hull is only known because of her teammate is to ignore the years of grind, discipline, and high-level performance she’s demonstrated, both in college and in the pros. The meme may have drawn attention to her, but the notion that she and Cunningham are only relevant because of Clark is reductive and unfair.
The Uneven Burden of Star Adjacency
Sports fans have always had complex relationships with star teammates. In many leagues, the secondary players around a superstar are either lionized for their loyalty or scrutinized for how they coexist with fame. In Clark’s case, the adoration is so intense that even light-hearted teasing from friends can be misread as antagonism. This reveals a deeper truth: proximity to greatness can sometimes come with invisible strings attached.
When you’re a teammate of someone as visible and polarizing as Clark, your every move gets magnified. Jokes turn into headlines. Memes become statements of intent. Cunningham’s meme wasn’t meant to insult—but because of who it referenced and how protective Clark’s fans are, it turned into a Rorschach test for online outrage.
Why This Isn’t a Betrayal, But a Sign of Trust
Teammates joke. That’s a fact of team sports. Locker rooms are filled with banter, jabs, and inside jokes. Cunningham’s meme fits within this context. And based on Clark’s public demeanor and her own sense of humor, it’s very likely she wasn’t offended at all. In fact, such teasing often signals closeness, not resentment.
In relationships grounded in trust, playful criticism is a sign of affection. The best teammates understand each other’s quirks and know when a joke is just a joke. Cunningham wouldn’t have posted the meme if she thought Clark would be genuinely upset—and Clark hasn’t indicated she was. Instead, it’s the internet that took offense on her behalf.
Context Is Everything: Why Sophie’s Reputation Matters
Over the course of her WNBA career, Cunningham has established a clear reputation. She’s passionate. She’s loyal. And above all, she’s protective of her people. The viral image was far from her first online joke—and probably won’t be her last. But it’s her real-life actions that matter most. When Clark needed someone in her corner during a physical matchup, Cunningham showed up. She’s not just a teammate—she’s a bodyguard in sneakers.
For those unfamiliar with her style, the meme might’ve felt out of place. But for fans who’ve followed Sophie’s career, this is exactly who she is: bold, brash, and deeply committed to her teammates.
The Bigger Picture: Rising Stars, Rising Expectations
What this minor controversy really reveals is the heightened tension surrounding Clark’s meteoric rise. With fame comes attention, and with attention comes overanalysis. Teammates, coaches, and even rivals now exist in a universe where every interaction with Caitlin Clark is put under a microscope.
Cunningham and Hull aren’t the first athletes to experience this. History is full of stories where the teammates of generational talents—be it Michael Jordan, Serena Williams, or Lionel Messi—struggled to exist in their own spotlight. That doesn’t mean they aren’t valuable or accomplished. It simply means their narratives get swept into the orbit of the superstar they play beside.
What’s Next for Sophie, Lexie, and Caitlin
In all likelihood, this controversy will blow over. But it does raise important questions about how we treat athletes who share space with icons. Sophie Cunningham didn’t stop being a fierce competitor or a devoted teammate because she posted a meme. Nor did Lexie Hull lose her credentials because she shared the spotlight.
Caitlin Clark will continue to break records and draw headlines. And Sophie Cunningham will likely continue to joke online while defending her teammates with the kind of grit and loyalty that has defined her career. If the Fever keep winning, these moments will become footnotes to a much bigger story—a story of a team figuring out how to thrive together in a world suddenly watching their every move.
Leave a Reply