The Philadelphia Phillies wrapped up a largely successful May with a few hiccups that saw them slip just behind the New York Mets in the National League East standings. Their early-season dominance has not gone unnoticed, but these recent struggles have prompted speculation about the front office’s strategy as the MLB trade deadline approaches. The Phillies, boasting a deep and experienced roster, are undeniably aiming for a postseason run, but much depends on how aggressive President of Baseball Operations Dave Dombrowski decides to be in bolstering the club for the stretch run.
A year ago, Philadelphia was widely expected to make bold moves at the trade deadline. There were rumors linking the team to high-profile players like reliever Tanner Scott and outfielder Luis Robert Jr. Instead, the Phillies opted for more conservative additions, acquiring Austin Hays and Carlos Estévez on short-term deals. Neither player re-signed, and ironically, Philadelphia once again finds itself short on both bullpen depth and consistent outfield production.
The Phillies’ core stars remain formidable. Bryce Harper continues to be a force in the middle of the lineup, Kyle Schwarber’s power remains a weapon, and Trea Turner brings elite athleticism and defense to the infield. But baseball is a team sport, and no matter how dominant the top-tier talent may be, sustained success requires contributions up and down the roster. One of the most pressing concerns is the bullpen, particularly after closer José Alvarado was suspended for a performance-enhancing drug violation, rendering him unavailable for the postseason.
The starting rotation is one of Philadelphia’s biggest strengths, featuring several all-stars and seasoned arms. However, the depth of the rotation makes it harder to find innings for younger pitchers, especially when the bullpen could use reinforcements. With a strong chance at a World Series push, Dombrowski and his staff may explore deals to upgrade in key areas, potentially involving prospects and younger players currently on the MLB roster.
As the trade deadline nears, several Phillies players stand out as possible trade candidates. Among them are promising infield prospect Aroon Escobar, struggling but toolsy outfielder Johan Rojas, and recently debuted pitcher Mick Abel. Each brings a different kind of value to the table, and each could attract interest from other organizations seeking young talent in exchange for veteran help.
Aroon Escobar (2B/3B/SS)
Escobar has been one of the Phillies’ most exciting minor league performers in 2024, showcasing a potent bat and defensive versatility at Low-A Clearwater. With a .924 OPS and a spot at No. 40 on The Athletic’s top 50 MLB prospects list, the 20-year-old has seen his stock rise sharply. If the Phillies aim to land a marquee player or a dependable everyday contributor at the deadline, Escobar would likely be a key asset in any trade talks.
Still, there are reasons to be cautious. Blue-chip prospects don’t grow on trees, and trading away someone with Escobar’s upside comes with significant risk. That said, Philadelphia’s infield is fairly crowded with talent. Aidan Miller, the organization’s No. 2 prospect and ranked ninth overall by The Athletic, is the same age as Escobar. Add in Bryson Stott’s emergence and Turner’s long-term contract, and it becomes difficult to envision Escobar cracking the big league roster in the near future.
In a theoretical future, the Phillies could field an infield of Harper at first base, Turner at shortstop, Stott at second base, and Miller potentially at third. Alec Bohm, while productive, may be the odd man out, making Escobar even more expendable. Escobar could be the centerpiece in a trade for a significant upgrade, especially if Dombrowski determines that the window to win is now. At the very least, his value has never been higher.
Johan Rojas (OF)
Rojas has long teased Phillies fans with tantalizing tools, particularly his defense in center field. At 24, he still has room to develop, but his continued offensive struggles are starting to test the organization’s patience. He remains one of the best defenders in MLB at his position and adds value with his speed and arm strength. However, his bat lags behind, making him the weakest hitter in Philadelphia’s regular lineup.
With the Phillies in urgent need of more production from the outfield, moving Rojas for a veteran bat could make sense. Brandon Marsh is slowly emerging from an early-season slump, and top prospect Justin Crawford is waiting in the wings with a more balanced skill set. This puts Rojas’s future in question.
Rojas still carries appeal across the league. A rebuilding team might take a chance on developing his offensive game, betting that his defensive floor gives them a reliable everyday contributor. For the Phillies, capitalizing on that market now could prove wise. If they wait too long and Rojas continues to struggle at the plate, his trade value could dip significantly. Moving him for someone who can contribute more immediately may better align with the team’s postseason ambitions.
Mick Abel (RHP)
Arguably the most intriguing trade chip is right-handed pitcher Mick Abel. After years of inconsistency, Abel dazzled in his MLB debut, throwing six shutout innings and flashing the stuff that made him a first-round pick. The 23-year-old is scheduled to make his second start soon and has rapidly reignited belief in his potential.
Despite this breakout, Abel’s path in Philadelphia is far from clear. The rotation already boasts five established All-Stars, not to mention Taijuan Walker’s hefty contract and Andrew Painter, a top-five prospect, advancing through his rehab. While “too much pitching” is a good problem to have, it does complicate Abel’s future with the club. Using him as a reliever might patch a short-term bullpen need, but could also stunt his long-term development.
For the Phillies, the key decision will be whether Abel is more valuable as a future contributor or as a trade piece who could help bring in an elite reliever or starting outfielder. Trading Abel won’t be easy, and the return would have to be significant. But if Philadelphia believes the time to win is now, they must at least consider all options.
Conclusion
With the trade deadline looming, the Philadelphia Phillies find themselves at a pivotal juncture. The team is loaded with stars and supported by a deep rotation, but injuries and underperformance in the bullpen and outfield have exposed areas of concern. Dave Dombrowski has been both aggressive and conservative in previous trade windows, but 2024 may demand bold action.
Players like Aroon Escobar, Johan Rojas, and Mick Abel represent valuable assets. Trading any of them would signal a win-now mentality but could also cost the organization future contributors. Ultimately, the Phillies have to strike a balance between long-term sustainability and maximizing their current title window. Fans and analysts alike will be watching closely as July approaches, waiting to see whether Philadelphia doubles down on its World Series aspirations or opts for a more measured approach.
Leave a Reply